Vince Copeland Archive   |   Trotskyist Writers Index   |   ETOL Main Page

V. Grey

Shop Talks on Socialism

The Gifts Socialism Bears

(28 September 1946)

From The Militant, Vol. X No. 39, 28 September 1946, p. 6.
Transcribed & marked up by Einde O’ Callaghan for the Encyclopaedia of Trotskyism On-Line (ETOL).

We have seen that declining capitalism carries its own seeds of destruction. The flames of war and the stench of famine are inseparable from this living-death. It was progressive once – and even though it sweated and tortured millions of workers it still increased the good things of the earth. Now in its dying period it is turning good into bad.

Capitalism gestated in the womb of dying feudalism. The lusty infant, in its day, pushed over kings and monarchies, fought revolutions so that the factory system might grow.

Now this capitalism, grown old and evil, likewise bears a brand new system within itself. It bears new life as well as death. Factory production only needs to be free of its out-moded individual ownership to be born anew.

The world working class is going to act as midwife in a forced birth. It is going to deliver the socialist future cut of the womb of the dying past.

Socialism will do many wonderful things. But as a bare minimum, as a sort of down payment, it will eliminate depressions, starvation and war. We know this for sure.

We found that capitalism is a system of production and exchange. It is a system under which individual capitalists own the means of production. The great majority of the people operate them. They represent values that the capitalist lays out so much cash for (VARIABLE CAPITAL). Their main product is SURPLUS VALUE (profit.)

The capitalist runs the factory, not to provide the world with shoes and suspenders, but to provide himself with profits. This leads to fiercer exploitation of the mass of workers on the one side; and a sharper aggravation of the capitalists’ own problems on the other, it leads to economic crashes, depressions and wars.

Socialism a Different System

Socialism is an entirely different system. The workers run the factories themselves. By doing so, they produce useful things instead of profits. They put an end to their own status as commodities. They are no longer bought and sold. They no longer have a “value” as they do under capitalism. And their aim is no longer to produce a surplus value above their own wages. Everything they produce is now theirs, and all the world’s.

They produce with an eye to what is needed. They elect a planning board to direct their production so they, don’t waste time and energy producing more than the world can use. Thus there are no unsold surpluses except for those they intend to have – if they need to build up a reserve. Thus no scramble for markets to dump the surplus, as under capitalism.

They can expand production without catastrophe – without throwing millions on the street to starve, without breeding wars to take up the products of expansion, as the capitalists do.

They can decide just where and what they want to expand, where expansion is needed and desirable. They can decide just how many workers shall be detailed to make new machinery and better equipment, just how many can be spared from the production of immediate consumers’ needs. There will be a planned expansion, with no explosions.

There will be world exchange of goods, of course. The U.S. workers would have a devil of a time trying to raise much coffee or rubber on northern soil. But they make automobiles rather easily. So they will send a number of automobiles to Brazil for their coffee and rubber supply.

Only a Beginning

But all this is only a beginning. The elimination of war and depression alone would give every human being at least 100 per cent more of the material goods of life. But it will do far more than that. It will reverse humanity’s present plunge downwards to destruction, and turn it into an equally rapid upward climb to glorious life.

Automobiles, airplanes, pleasure parks and palaces – all the things .that can already be made so easily, will be within everyone’s reach. Still newer products will be made. Newer needs will be felt.

In a short time, material needs will not seem so. important. People will require more beauty in their lives. New spiritual needs will arise. They will be satisfied. But there will be no terrible decline again. For when we come to the top of the hill, we can throw up new heights to climb. The masters of production will become masters of their own destiny.

The above is the final installment in a series of articles on Marxist economics.

Vince Copeland Archive   |   Trotskyist Writers Index  |   ETOL Main Page

Last updated: 19 June 2021